Showing posts with label Scotch. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Scotch. Show all posts

Wednesday, October 7, 2026

Whisk(e)y Wednesday 2026-10-07

Here we go for another Whisk(e)y Wednesday. I was traveling last week, but I'm back and ready for some Whisk(e)y.

On the nose, this one is mild, not getting much other than alcohol. Nose seems a bit flat overall. The taste, fruit, sweet, ash, pepper, bbq, spicy. The finish has heat up front, then sweet, then back to the heat with some char.

With water, the nose is similar, I get some more heat on the nose now, so maybe it's not as low proof as I thought. It is sweeter on the taste, and the finish does linger nicely and has some ash now too. I'm not sure what to think, it feels a bit flat and young. The nose is oddly a let down compared to the taste, and usually I think peated Scotch (which I'm guessing this is) has a better nose than taste. I'll rate this a 3.75/5.0 tonight.

This ended up being Lagavulin 12 Year Cask Strength, 57.3% ABV. I had this back in 24 Days of Whisk(e)y 2023 and I rated it a 4.5/5.0 that night. I do have a woozy of this saved so I'll have to give it another try - but this is one of those Whiskies that if I know I'm drinking it, I enjoy it more because I know more what to expect and I know historically I enjoy it - so I try enjoying it, if that makes sense. Anyway ... that's the fun part of blind tastings.

Wednesday, September 9, 2026

Whisk(e)y Wednesday 2026-09-09

Whisk(e)y Wednesday Time - random sample, let's see what I think.

On the nose, this is peaty, phenol, rubber... this is my type of whisky for sure. The taste, I get sweet bqq meat, savory. The finish, sweet bbq meat, some ash, hot pepper, lingers nicely. I'd guess this is mid proof, 50% ABV or so, and I am thinking peated Scotch.

With water, there seems to be more proof and pepper on the nose, sweeter taste, and a hotter finish. I am enjoying this, I'll rate it a 4.25/5.0 ... I'll guess it's a one off Ardbeg.

Turns out it was the Port Askaig 110 Proof, no age statement. I had this during 24 Days of Whisk(e)y 2025 and rated it a 4.0 that night. Pretty tasty stuff, might have to pick up another bottle sometime. Cheers!

Wednesday, August 26, 2026

Whisk(e)y Wednesday 2026-08-26

Hump ... DAY! Whisk(e)y Wednesday Time. Random Sample Time ... here we go (:

On the nose, this is super peaty. Phenol, rubber, seems mid proof... 45%-50% I'd guess. The taste is sweet, meaty, rubber and some band-aid too. The finish is medicine and sweet. At first I was thinking Ardbeg for sure, but with the band-aid... maybe Laphroaig, but there I would think the Cask Strength instead of the standard 10 Year, and it doesn't seem that high proof.

With water, the nose is similar, maybe getting some ash and char now. The taste is more sweet and mellow, though some hot spice and ash in the back. The finish I am finding ash as well, with the sweet and meat. 

The nose on this is fantastic, the taste and finish is a bit one note. This does seem better with water, I'm going to guess it's one of the one-off Ardbegs I have, and it's hitting my taste buds tonight and I'll rate it 4.25/5.0.

This was the Ardbeg Heavy Vapors standard release (46% ABV - no age statement) from a few years ago. It doesn't look like I've reviewed this one before, and the bottle is long gone, so this sample was the last of it. It cost $131.95 when I bought it. Even though I rated it high tonight, I'm betting any of the standard Ardbegs would have been as well rated tonight (:

Wednesday, June 17, 2026

Whisk(e)y Wednesday 2026-06-17

Whisk(e)y ... WEDNESDAY!!!

Random sample time - let's see what we have this evening. On the nose, I get hits of orange, malt, a touch of sulfur I think - but just a touch and some vanilla. The taste I get orange, malt, some black pepper and vanilla. The finish is malty and vanilla. This feels maybe mid proof, around 50% ABV I would guess, and my first hunch is Scotch, maybe something like Compass Box Glasgow Blend.

With water, the nose is very similar, but more sweet. The taste is more sweet too but feels more plain as well. On the finish I now get a touch of sulfur. Overall this is pretty nice.. I almost gave it a 4.0/5.0 - but I'll call it a 3.75/5.0 instead. 

Turns out we were drinking Ardnamurchan Highland Single Malt Whisky, 46.8% ABV. I did almost scream "SCOTCH!" so I'm glad I got that part right (: Cheers!

Wednesday, June 10, 2026

Whisk(e)y Wednesday 2026-06-10

Another random sample for Whisk(e)y Wednesday - let's see what we have tonight.

On the nose, this is honey, mint, malt ... fairly mild. I would lean Irish, maybe an American Single Malt ... I suppose possibly a non-peated Scotch. Seems pretty low ABV on the nose, 90ish proof I'm guessing. The taste is bright-citrus with some spice too. The finish is malty, honey, cereal, fruit on the back end... I don't think it's apple, but maybe? I'm thinking maybe *not* Irish, hmm.

With water, the nose is still minty, with floral and honey too. The taste and finish seem more mild and malty. My final thought is this will be a middle of the road Irish - lower proof, maybe even 40% ABV as that's a popular point for Irish Whiskies. Tonight I would rate this a 3.5/5.0 - it's good but not great.

Turns out this was Compass Box, Glasgow Blend, Blended Scotch Whisky, 43% ABV, no color added, non-chill filtered. I originally had this in 2024's 24 Days of Whisk(e)y and at that time I rated it 3.75/5.0, so in the same ball park... cheers!

Wednesday, June 3, 2026

Whisk(e)y Wednesday 2026-06-03

Back from vacation - time for another Whisk(e)y Wednesday, so here goes another random sample.

On the nose, peaty, rubber, phenol ... the nose is very nice, I could just sniff this all night long. It seems very Ardbeg - it's sweet too. The taste is sweet bbq along with the char and ash and peat. This has to be an Ardbeg. It seems a bit high proof so many it's a Cask Strength Committee Release. 

The finish is heat and sweet with smoke in the back. With water, the nose is similar though it may have more char. The taste is very sweet then more char. The finish is spicy and nice. This is really good and I would rate it 4.25/5.0.

Well, it is an Ardbeg... but not a Committee Release. It's Ardbeg Wee Beastie - Aged 5 Years, 47.4% ABV. This one keeps surprising me how good it is when I have it blind. I really need to pick up a new bottle (:

Wednesday, April 15, 2026

Whisk(e)y Wednesday 2026-04-15

Another head to head matchup with bottles from the 2025 24 Days of Whisk(e)y ... plus a bonus one as well (: We are trying out the peated Scotch Whiskies this time, the lineup is ...

Port Askaig 110 Proof (that's the name... and the proof, go figure!) 55% ABV
Highland Park 12 Year 43% ABV
Compass Box Peat Monster Cask Strength 56.7% ABV
Kilchoman Cask Strength 57% ABV

and the bonus pour is ...

Ardbeg Wee Beastie (5 Year) 47.4% ABV

The Ardbeg I haven't taste tested since 2020 and I thought it might be a good addition to the mix. I poured these and randomized them - let's see what I think about them.

Glass 1 : Nose is sweet and BBQ, some rubber and some dirt too. The taste is sweet with ash and some pepper. The finish is heat, ash in the back with some sweet too. This seems well balanced for sure, I'll rate is a 4.25 today as I really enjoyed it.

Glass 2 : Nose I get some ash, some sweet and some char. The nose seems hotter and on the 2nd round I get a touch of mint too. The taste is hot spice, some sweet, ash, tar ... and then more sweet. The finish is hot pepper, then sugar, it lingers nicely, then I get some simple syrup and ash way in the back. I'll rate it a 4.0.

Glass 3 : I get a sweet BBQ and pepper. On the second nose I get more heat and ash in the back. The taste is candy sweet, with some ash and char too - peppery after a bit. The finish i candy sweet as well, then pepper, a nice tingle with some heat. I will say that this feels one note-ish to me, but that note is good. I'll rate it a 4.0 as well.

Glass 4 : This one seems less peaty on the nose ... it's sweet and has some heat too. The taste does have some ash, along with some sweet and pepper. The finish is peppery that turns to sweet and savory, it lingers with a nice tingle. I'll will also rate this one 4.0.

Glass 5 : I get matchstick on the nose, some sulfur and some sweet as well. The taste is fruity with some sweet, some matchstick and this is a bit prickly - it's a bit proofy. The finish is fruity, sweet and has some sulfur as well. I'll rate this one 4.25.

Trying the ones I rated 4.0 - I'd have to say Glass 3 was my least favorite, with Glass 2 being my favorite of the 3. Which means Glass 2, Port Askaig was #3 tonight, with Glass 4, the Highland Park being #4, and Glass 3, the Compass Box coming in last place. It was a tough crowd for sure.

Trying Glass 1 vs Glass 5 ... I have to give it to Glass 1. Glass 5 turned out to be the Kilchoman, and was #2 tonight. Which leaves Ardbeg Wee Beastie as my favorite for the night. I currently don't have a bottle of this, and should pick up another one for sure. Cheers!

Wednesday, April 1, 2026

Whisk(e)y Wednesday 2026-04-01

Tonight we are going to try 5 non-Islay Scotch Whiskies - which usually means non-peated, but not always. Anyway, the lineup is...

Bunnahabhain Stiuireadair, Single Malt Scotch Whisky, 46.3% ABV
Compass Box Spice Tree, Blended Scotch Whisky, 46.0% ABV
The Macallan 12 Year Sherry Oak, 43.0% ABV
Deer, Bear & Moose 2011, Highland Single Malt Scotch Whisky, Distilled at Isle of Jura Distillery, Scotland, Aged 11 Years, Natural Cask Strength, 59.2% ABV
Ardnamurchan, Western Highlands Single Malt Scotch Whisky, 46.8% ABV

I generally enjoyed these during 24 Days of Whisk(e)y 2025, Deer, Bear & Moose, Bunnahabhain and The Macallan I rated 4.0/5.0, while the Compass Box and Ardnamurchan I rated 3.75/5.0

Glass 1 : On the nose, butterscotch, touch of proof/spice/heat. Once acclimated there seemed to be less proof. The taste is sweet, peppery, spicy, hot. The finish is Crème Brûlée, simple syrup, pepper, hot cinnamon - it lingers quite some time, really enjoyable. I'm guessing this is between 50% ABV and 55% ABV. With water, similar nose, taste is hotter but still sweet and peppery, the finish is still hot peppery with sweet and maybe a little meaty bbq. Tonight this is just hitting nicely, I'll get it a 4.25/5.0[

Glass 2 : The nose has flora, sweet, some heat and butterscotch. The taste is floral with some baking spice and potpourri. The finish I get a bit of make up talcum powder, drifts off pretty quickly, I'm guessing this is 45% ABV or so. With water, nose is similar, taste and finish similar too. I'll rate this one a 3.75/5.0. 

Glass 3 : I get vanilla frosting, maybe a touch of sulfur on the nose - seems more sweet going back to it. The taste seems thin, some wood, dry. The finish is woody and some pepper, There is a bit of spice and heat there too, but I'm guessing this is around 45% ABV. With water, I still get vanilla frosting on the nose, the taste is more sweet and more peppery, finish is about the same. I would rate this a 3.75/5.0 tonight.

Glass 4 : For the nose, I get matchstick sulfur and fruit jam. The taste I get some matchstick and burnt rubber, some charred wood as well. The finish continues with the matchstick with some pepper, hangs around for a while, pretty enjoyable. I would guess this is between 45% ABV and 50% ABV. With water the nose turns a little sour, but still some matchstick. Taste is similar, finish seems sweeter with some bbq meat as well. This is pretty good overall, I'll rate it a 4.0.

Glass 5 : On the nose I'm getting a touch of matchstick, sweet candy, very sweet. The taste is matchstick, some burnt sugar, seems around 45% ABV. The finish is peppery tingle, dry, lingers for some time. With water the nose is similar, taste more sweet as is the finish. This was certainly a nice pour, and I'll rate it 4.0.

Glass 2 and 3 were bringing up the rear, and I'll have to say glass 3 was my least favorite, which was the Compass Box. Glass 2 was the Bunnahabhain. These were still very tasty. The next tier had glass 4 and 5... and I'd have to say Glass 5, The Macallan, I enjoyed more than the Ardnamurchan.

Which means Glass 1 was my favorite, The Deer, Bear & Moose 2011. It certainly doesn't seem like it's 59.2% ABV. I do wonder with doing 5 in short succession if there was cross contamination for the nose/taste/finish notes, but all these were mighty tasty.

Wednesday, February 18, 2026

Whisk(e)y Wednesday 2026-02-18

Hump DAY!!!! Another go with a random sample ... let's see what tonight brings.

On the nose, this is very sweet, and I get rubber, fudge, some proof, maybe around 50% ABV, but I don't think this is cask strength. It's giving me peated single malt vibes ... but it could be a peated American Single Malt too. The taste I get fig, sweet frosting then sweet bbq and a nice hot spice. The finish is pepper, char, sweet marshmallow with some ash at the end. This is really good and hitting all the bells for me tonight.

With water, there seems to be more proof on the nose, still sweet too. Sweeter on taste, but still has the sweet bbq meat and some tar that turns into hot spice. The finish is pepper hot with sweet in the back. Overall this is quite nice, guessing Peated Scotch Whisky, 50% ABV and I'll rate it 4.0/5.0 tonight. It could be Port Charlotte as that is the right proof point and this reminds me of that somewhat.

We were drinking Deer, Bear & Moose, Isle of Jura 2011 Single Malt Scotch Whisky. It comes in at 59.2% ABV ... which I was caught off guard when I had this during 24 Days of Whisk(e)y as well. It just drinks much lower. This is a Flaviar exclusive and I believe cost me around $70... so *well* worth it in my opinion. 

Wednesday, January 21, 2026

Whisk(e)y Wednesday - 2026-01-21

Another Whisk(e)y Wednesday, another random sample. On with the show!

On the nose, I get Crème brûlée, burnt sugar, and a touch of sulfur. The taste as burnt brown sugar, molasses, simple syrup, along with a matchstick sulfur. There seems to be some heat in the back. 

The finish is brown sugar, molasses, maybe some mesquite style smoke, and some char. With water the nose is more sweet, the taste is more hot spicy pepper along with the sweet, and the finish is more hot pepper too. 

Overall this is nice, and it grew on my as I sipped it, I'll give it a 4.0/5.0 tonight. It seemed young, so I'm thinking a smoked or peated American Single Malt, at around 55% ABV. Looking up what I was drinking, it was a Blended Scotch, Black Bull 12 Year from Duncan Taylor, 50% ABV. I reviewed this as part of 24 Days of Whisk(e)y 2024 and rated it a 4.0 that evening as well. I paid $43 for the bottle and would certainly pick up another at that price.

Tuesday, December 23, 2025

24 Days of Whisk(e)y - Day 23

Next to last one of the 24 Days of Whisk(e)y ... I know how many of the various types of whisk(e)y I bought, so as long as I didn't mess anything up, tonight should be a Scotch (:

On the nose... it sure seems like Scotch. Malty, floral, honey, a hint of smoke. There is alcohol present on the nose, but it doesn't seem overly strong, maybe around 45% ABV or so. The taste is honey, pepper and a little smoke and ash. The finish is black pepper with ash at the end that lingers. 

Water initially brings more alcohol to the nose, but then highlights the honey. The taste seems a bit warmer as well, and the black pepper on the finish seems more like a hot pepper, and there seems to be less ash on the finish too. Overall, this is nice - could sit and sip on this one all evening. I'll rate it 3.75/5.0.


Tonight's bottle was Ardnamurchan, Highland Single Malt Scotch Whisky, 46.8% ABV, no age statement, from Glenbeg, Ardnamurchan Scotland. This one cost a bit under $70. I don't recall why I bought this bottle - I might have seen a review of it, or maybe it was just a random purchase to round things out. Either way, I give it a thumbs up. 

Tuesday, December 16, 2025

24 Days of Whisk(e)y - Day 16

Tuesday Whisk(e)y Time! Tonight... on the nose, peaty! I get the malt, ash, medicinal, toffee, some chocolate. I keep going back and fining more, including some savory bbq meat, really quite nice, the nose is excellent. The taste I get the sweet and savory, peppery heat, toffee, smoke and ash... and then even more pepper. As I acclimate to this, I also find on the taste the bbq meat I found on the nose. The finish has a spicy heat tingle on the tongue, char and ash that drifts away to be replaced with sweet toffee ... and then finally the heat comes back to linger.

With water the nose is similar, the taste seems more spicy and the finish is more sweet. This is quite excellent overall and well balanced. I'm pretty sure it's a peated Scotch, and I think it's probably around 55% ABV so likely cask strength. This is the best of the year so far... I don't think I can quite go to 4.5 for this, so I'll call it 4.25/5.0 - tonight bottle is...


Kilchoman Batch Strength Islay Single Malt Scotch Whisky. 57% ABV, no age statement. I've had other Kilchoman Scotch Whiskys before, but I'm pretty sure this is the only Cask Strength one, and this is certainly better than the other ones I've tried. A winner for sure, cheers!

Saturday, December 13, 2025

24 Days of Whisk(e)y - Day 13

Today was reasonably nice, got out and about for a bit, even got in a 5K run around the neighborhood - and now, time to drink some booze (:

The nose is malt, honey, molasses, marshmallow... I do seem to get a little sulfur or something earthy I can't quite place. At first I thought it might be peated, but the more I smell, the less I'm leaning that way. The taste is peppery, sweet molasses and fresh orange peel. The finish is malt, some pepper and then sweet at the end.

With water, it seems more peppery on the nose, and I think I do get some sulfur too. The taste is sweeter while the finish seems to get a little ashy. I'm guessing this is around 50% ABV and I will rate it a 4.0/5.0 - I do think it's Scotch, and it seems a little thin overall and I think it could be better balanced, but I do enjoy it. 



Ok, not what I was expecting. In the past, I have found Macallan Whisky to be smooth and a bit boring ... but still quite tasty, just not too exciting. This one seemed a little more interesting overall. Macallan Highland Single Malt Scotch Whisky, Sherry Oak Cask, 43% ABV, 12 Year Old. This one cost right about $100, and while I enjoy it enough, I doubt I would buy it again.

Saturday, December 6, 2025

24 Days of Whisk(e)y - Day 6

Day 6 of 24 Days of Whisk(e)y ... let's see what we have tonight.

On the nose, this is soft and subtle, with some soft notes of floral and honey. The taste is mild as well, with some honey and spices with some wood as well, but everything is light. After a sip I can get a little bit of the spice on the nose, mild baking spice.

The finish I get some bread, honey, wood dryness, and some warmth that builds over time. I would guess this is around 45% ABV, and I'm thinking it's an Irish Whiskey. Adding a little water, the nose is similar, more baking spice on the taste, and more of that spice on the finish too. 

I'd rate this a 3.75/5.0 - I do like it better than the bourbons that we've had so far, and I enjoy it like the Scotch last night, so I'll rate it the same. Tonight's bottle is ...



Well, Irish... Scotch - they're close on the map, right? Compass Box Spice Tree, Blended Malt Scotch Whisky, all coming from the Highlands and about 11 to 12 years of age. After knowing it is Scotch, the tasting notes are not too surprising. A solid offering from Compass Box, we'll see what tomorrow brings.

Friday, December 5, 2025

24 Days of Whisk(e)y - Day 5

Happy Friday! It's booze-o-clock ... so time to drink some whisk(e)y and see if I like it or not.

This one has a nice color to it, and the nose has honey, a touch of nail polish, toffee, floral, a touch of talcum powder ... overall it's light. The taste - I get sweet tobacco, pepper, that talcum powder again, and if I'm looking for it, some ash.

The finish brings the tobacco, some wood, some hot pepper, a touch of sour malt, maybe even a light hint of dill. This does have some heat that builds as well, but I think it's just from the spice - not the proof - I would guess the proof is 46% ABV... and this sure does seem like an unpeated Scotch.

Adding water, it's sweeter on the taste, more pepper on the finish, and the nose has more toffee. Overall, I would rated this a 3.75/5.0 ... it's good, nothing offensive, but also nothing overly great about it. I am enjoying it though. Tonight we were drinking ...


Highland Park Viking Honour, Single Malt Whisky, 43% ABV. Distilled by Highland Park Distillery, Kirkwall, Orkney Islands, Scotland. This is generally considered peated - and I guess if I go hunting for it, I can find some peat, and I will say, the more I drink, the more the peat seems to be there. I have not had this one for a while, and was curious how it would do blind. At $59 a bottle - there are better things to buy, but this is still a solid whisky.

Wednesday, December 3, 2025

24 Days of Whisk(e)y - Day 3

Hump ... DAY! Whisk(e)y Wednesday (:

Ready to check this one out. The nose is faint and malty. First thought is an Irish or Scotch. I get some apple, pear and honey as well. The taste is apple and malty - but it seems more like a Scotch than an Irish Whiskey, that's for sure.

The finish is nice - malty, does hang around for a while with a touch of spice on the backend. This seemed around 45% ABV so I was hesitant to add water - and water turned it even more sweet, certainly better without

Overall, I like this quite a bit, giving it a 4.0/5.0. 



Tonight we were drinking Bunnahabhain Stiùireadair, Islay Single Malt Scotch Whisky, 46.3% ABV, Distilled on Islay, Scotland - no age statement, but estimated to be a blend of 7 to 10 year, unpeated. I tasted it a bit more after knowing what it was - and I did find a little bit of talcum powder as well, which is something I have found in unpeated Scotch before. This cost me just under $50, at that price I give this a thumbs up, cheers!

Tuesday, December 2, 2025

24 Days of Whisk(e)y - Day 2

Happy Tuesday ... Treat Tuesday? Most certainly! Tonight ... it looks like Scotch ... it smells like Scotch ... I'm betting it's Scotch. (or American Single Malt...)

On the nose... it's got the rubbery peat, some bbq meat, something sweet like molasses. It doesn't seem too proofy, I can go in pretty good while nosing. Some honey too, and I thought I might be getting some brine/salt as well.

The taste ... ash that comes out of nowhere up front, a little bit of peppery hot, spicy, then sweet. It feels a little disjointed. I like it, but ... it seems to lack something. Going back to the nose after the first sip - I am getting the ash on the nose as well now. The finish is more ash, some pepper heat, sweet in the back.

Adding water, I get more proof on the nose, and more sweet on the taste, and a LOT more sweet on the finish. Overall, this is OK. I tend to like peaty Scotch - even ones that are not that great or balanced. This one seems to be a bit random, but I'd still give it a 4.0/5.0. Tonight ... the bottle was...


Port Askaig 110° - Islay Single Malt Scotch Whisky, no age statement, coming in at 55% ABV or ... 110 proof (: Distilled on Islay, Scotland - apparently Port Askaig isn't the distillery... it's just the name of the Whisky and they source from various distilleries on Islay. I've had a few other Port Askaigs in the past, including a 100° that was really 114 proof that was a bit harsh when I had it early in my Scotch journey, an 8 year that I thought was OK, and a 19 Year that I rated a 4.0 but at the time I wasn't doing quarter ratings and I'm guessing I would have given it a 4.25 as I do recall enjoying it quite a bit. Overall I'd say Port Askaig isn't quite as well rounded as the larger distilleries on Islay (though who knows who they source this from...), but if you really like Islay Whisky - it's worth checking out.

Sunday, November 30, 2025

Whisk(e)y ... Sunday?

With 24 Days of Whisk(e)y starting up tomorrow, I figured I'd do a blind sample tonight to get in the mood (: What will the random offering be tonight...

On the nose, I get honey, mild, bubble gum, and alcohol that initially is hard to get past. Going back I do find some smoke and some bbq meat. The taste, I get strawberry, cinnamon, spicy, heat. Some rubber in the back. I can't quite place this one, and I'm wondering if I'm just off tonight.

The finish is fruity, sweet, cinnamon... not getting any oak. There is some sweet bbq as well. I don't have a good guess on this - I'm guessing it's around 50% ABV, it does seem like a peated scotch, but other than that ... not sure. And it was.... Laphroaig 10 Year Cask Strength, 58.5% ABV. Which is surprising to me. After knowing what it is, I can find more peat and smoke, but I'm not really getting any Laphroaig notes overall. Tonight I rated it 4.0/5.0 - last year I rated it 4.25/5.0 - and looking at my tasting notes from last year I enjoyed it quite a bit more than I did this time.

Wednesday, November 26, 2025

Whisk(e)y Wednesday - 2025-11-26

Another random blind sample... here we go! Tonight's pour is light in color, so light my first guess is Ardbeg, but I'm getting ahead of myself a bit here. The nose... rubber, sweet bbq, touch of sour malt, campfire, ash, and char. The taste is ash, peat, spicy, hot pepper, sweet bbq meat, and char.

The finish, I get some burnt sugar, hot pepper that is a bit punchy and lingers. More sweet way in the back. Overall, this feels a bit random - the flavors are not overly cohesive. It's still pretty good, and I do expect it to be a one-off Ardbeg, I'll rate it 4.0/5.0 tonight.

And - it was Ardbeg. Scorch Committee Release, 51.7% ABV. I had this during 24 Days of Whisk(e)y in 2021 and rated it 4.0/5.0 that time as well. I did like the Committee release version better than the standard version back then.

Wednesday, November 12, 2025

Whisk(e)y Wednesday - 2025-11-12

Here we are again, Whisk(e)y Wednesday. Let's see how we like this one tonight.

On the nose, it's malty and I get some sulfur, marshmallow, honey, an artificial sweetener note as well... which sounds a bit odd, but it's what I was reminded of. Going back to the nose after acclimation I don't really find the sulfur as much. The taste I get some matchstick, peppery, hot, malt, sweet, candy. It feels over 50% ABV, but it is the first drink of the evening, so it could just be drinking a bit hot. This does seem to get sweeter the longer I drink it, along with being jammy.

The finish is sweet initially, malt that lingers, with matchstick, hot pepper, and a bit of artificial sweetener like I get from rum. Very sweet, jammy. Overall this struck me a pretty good, but not quite great... I'd rate it a 4.25/5.0 tonight, but I can't quite place what it might be. Not Ardbeg, I don't think it's Laphroaig either... don't have any great guesses. 

Turns out it was BenRiach, The Smoky 12, 46% ABV. I originally rated it 4.0/5.0, so I just liked it a bit more this evening. At $60 I might want to pick up another bottle sometime, though Ardbeg 10 comes in around there too, and I probably like that one more.