Showing posts with label Makers Mark. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Makers Mark. Show all posts

Wednesday, February 25, 2026

Whisk(e)y Wednesday 2026-02-25

Another Wednesday, another blind sample. Let's see what we have tonight.

On the nose, I'm getting mint, honey... and it seems like a touch of sulfur? Maybe my glass wasn't very clean (: The taste, honey, pepper, it seems proofy. I think I'm getting some dill as well, along with some burnt sugar and wood. The finish - sugar, wood, baking cinnamon - it's oily and clingy. 

With water, more mint on the nose, still proofy. I get some sweet on the nose too. Mint, pickle and peppery on the taste, with the finish being more wood. Overall tonight this just seemed too proofy, I'd guess 60% ABV. Seems like it's a rye, and it's just not doing it for me - I'd rate this one a 3.5/5.0

Tonight we were drinking Maker's Mark Cask Strength, batch 22-04, coming in at 55% ABV. I had this during 24 Days of Whisk(e)y in 2024 and I rated it 3.5/5.0 and generally liked it better. After knowing it was bourbon I did get more bourbon notes from the nose and taste - I guess I was just off tonight... cheers!

Wednesday, March 19, 2025

Whisk(e)y Wednesday - 2025-03-19

OK - at it again, tonight I am drinking the four Bourbons from the 2024 24 Days of Whisk(e)y in a blind flight. We'll see what I think this time...


I poured 1oz samples into each of the glasses that have been labeled on the bottom and mixed them up. I then nosed and tasted each one, came up with my favorite two, tasted those again side by side, and decided on the best of the bunch and rated each one again as well. 

Glass 1) On the nose, I get some peanut, cinnamon, brown sugar, molasses and a touch of dusty along with some dill. On the taste - this is the first drink of the day, and it initially came across hot - red hot cinnamon hot. With a few more sips, it does tame down a bit, and I get some brown sugar, a touch of lemon, a touch of wood, and the dusty note again. The finish is cinnamon, a touch of spice, brown sugar, some tingle near the end, and a bit of dill way in the back. Overall this is solid - I put it on par with my go to budget Wild Turkey 101 - so I'll rate it a 3.25/5.0

Glass 2) On the nose, I get some floral, honey, brown sugar and some spearmint. The taste is brown sugar, hot cinnamon and mint. The mint carries over to the finish, along with some spice, a touch of wood as well. The finish hangs around for some time and builds. The more I drink this, the more I like it - leaning towards 3.5/5.0 for this one.

Glass 3) The nose I find bubble gum, cherry cough drop, light molasses. The taste is a bit flat, but the cherry cough drop does come through. The finish is not very strong, but it does linger. The cherry sweetness is the biggest note, but I do get a little wood/oak in the back as well. This one just isn't hitting for me tonight, and I'll give it a 3.0/5.0

Glass 4) The nose I get cherry, brown sugar, touch of menthol and maybe some tobacco - though that could just be the menthol suggesting tobacco to me. The taste is a bit watery, some baking spice, cinnamon heat that builds over time. The finish I get a cherry menthol cough drop note, come wood, some cinnamon heat. It's all right overall. Initially I liked this the best, but the more I went back to it, the more I found it lacking, giving it a 3.25/5.0

Glass 3 was the Tin Cup 14 Year. It just didn't do well head to head with higher proof offerings - at least in a quick shoot out format. I enjoyed it more a few months ago, but tonight it just fell flat. Original rating was 3.5, tonight it was a 3.0. Glass 4 was the Cooper's Craft. It wasn't bad, but there was nothing unusual about it. Standard bourbon. Rated 3.00 originally, 3.25 tonight.

Which left glass 1 and 2. Glass 1 was the Baker's 7 Year, 107 Proof. This was solid and tasty, but glass 2 was a touch better, which was the Maker's Mark Cask Strength, 55% ABV. Tonight it was the most interesting. Originally I gave the Baker's a 3.75 rating, tonight I gave it a 3.25. And the Maker's received a 3.50 rating both nights.

Next week, we have 4 Rye Whiskies head to head... we'll see which one I enjoy the most, cheers!




Tuesday, December 3, 2024

2024 24 Days of Whisk(e)y - Day 3

Day 3 ... tonight, we're drinking Maker's Mark Cask Strength, 55% ABV. After two Irish Whiskeys, this was a nice change. How was it? Let's find out... 

Initially on the nose, I wasn't getting much of anything. I had a little bit of the alcohol burn that should have clued me into the higher proof on this one. Eventually I did get typical bourbon notes including molasses/caramel, some red fruit and maybe a light pepper note, though that could have just been the proof.

The taste had some sweet along with some dry wood in the back. I got more of that peppery tingle, though again, sometimes proof can come across as peppery/spicy. I thought for a second this could have been a rye. But every time I went back for another sip it did get more typical bourbon. The finish seemed more spicy, with a lot of dry wood and some cherry.

Water didn't change things much, I could drink this either way. This one cost me $42 when I bought it, and for that price, it's pretty good overall. My biggest complaint is that it was a bit flat overall, and surprisingly soft for the proof. I would rate it 3.5/5.0.

Wednesday, September 27, 2023

Whisk(e)y Wednesday - 2023-09-27 (I'm back!)

Hello! Well, it's time to start getting back in 'whiskey' shape for the upcoming 24 Days of Whisk(e)y... tonight, I'm drinking Maker's Mark No. 46 - Cask Strength Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whisky (no e?). This one was finished with ten virgin French oak staves, coming in at 55.05% ABV, batch 23-02.


Time to give this a try. On the nose - there is a lot going on, there is some citrus, along with a candy cherry note. I get some milk chocolate and/or toffee, and some peppery spice. It's quite nice and isn't overpowering. 

On the taste - the peppery spice comes through first for me, along with the chocolate cherry and a bit of grass in there too. The finish is similar with the candy cherry / chocolate up front, peppery spice in the back. The finish lingers for quite some time and you do get some wood bite eventually. 

With a dash of water, the nose is more sweet and herbal, while the taste is a bit more sweet and with more chocolate - the finish gets a bit more wood... it might be better with a dash of water to be honest. Overall this is quite good - what you would expect from a large distillery releasing a cask strength bottle around $65 or so. I give this a 3.75/5.0 ... the bottle disappeared a lot quicker than expected. Cheers!!!

Wednesday, November 25, 2020

Whisk(e)y Wednesday - 2020-11-25

Hump Day! And I had the day off ... and the next 4 days off too, woo... Time to celebrate! Today I'm doing a head to head comparison between Maker's Mark Private Select, coming in at 54.5% ABV and Remus Repeal Reserve Series IV Straight Bourbon Whiskey, 50% ABV, aged 12 years.


First up, Maker's Mark. On the nose, I get oak and some brown sugar, along with some cinnamon, clove and other spices. Nothing too surprising on the taste, certainly Maker's Mark, with brown sugar, cinnamon. and spice. Water seems to bring out the sweetness and brown sugar, while rounding off the edges - I probably prefer it with some water. I'll rate it 3.5 / 5.0.

Onto Remus Repeal Reserve. I reviewed Series II and liked it, so I split a bottle of Series IV with a friend. Very nice on the nose, with caramel and toffee and a hint of wood. The taste has a nice rye like spice along with some caramel. Quite good. For me, water brings out more of the wood. I prefer this one neat. I think I like this one over the Maker's Mark, I'll rate it 3.75 / 5.0 (which is the same rating I gave Series II). Cheers, and Happy Thanksgiving (: