Showing posts with label Macallan. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Macallan. Show all posts

Wednesday, April 1, 2026

Whisk(e)y Wednesday 2026-04-01

Tonight we are going to try 5 non-Islay Scotch Whiskies - which usually means non-peated, but not always. Anyway, the lineup is...

Bunnahabhain Stiuireadair, Single Malt Scotch Whisky, 46.3% ABV
Compass Box Spice Tree, Blended Scotch Whisky, 46.0% ABV
The Macallan 12 Year Sherry Oak, 43.0% ABV
Deer, Bear & Moose 2011, Highland Single Malt Scotch Whisky, Distilled at Isle of Jura Distillery, Scotland, Aged 11 Years, Natural Cask Strength, 59.2% ABV
Ardnamurchan, Western Highlands Single Malt Scotch Whisky, 46.8% ABV

I generally enjoyed these during 24 Days of Whisk(e)y 2025, Deer, Bear & Moose, Bunnahabhain and The Macallan I rated 4.0/5.0, while the Compass Box and Ardnamurchan I rated 3.75/5.0

Glass 1 : On the nose, butterscotch, touch of proof/spice/heat. Once acclimated there seemed to be less proof. The taste is sweet, peppery, spicy, hot. The finish is Crème Brûlée, simple syrup, pepper, hot cinnamon - it lingers quite some time, really enjoyable. I'm guessing this is between 50% ABV and 55% ABV. With water, similar nose, taste is hotter but still sweet and peppery, the finish is still hot peppery with sweet and maybe a little meaty bbq. Tonight this is just hitting nicely, I'll get it a 4.25/5.0[

Glass 2 : The nose has flora, sweet, some heat and butterscotch. The taste is floral with some baking spice and potpourri. The finish I get a bit of make up talcum powder, drifts off pretty quickly, I'm guessing this is 45% ABV or so. With water, nose is similar, taste and finish similar too. I'll rate this one a 3.75/5.0. 

Glass 3 : I get vanilla frosting, maybe a touch of sulfur on the nose - seems more sweet going back to it. The taste seems thin, some wood, dry. The finish is woody and some pepper, There is a bit of spice and heat there too, but I'm guessing this is around 45% ABV. With water, I still get vanilla frosting on the nose, the taste is more sweet and more peppery, finish is about the same. I would rate this a 3.75/5.0 tonight.

Glass 4 : For the nose, I get matchstick sulfur and fruit jam. The taste I get some matchstick and burnt rubber, some charred wood as well. The finish continues with the matchstick with some pepper, hangs around for a while, pretty enjoyable. I would guess this is between 45% ABV and 50% ABV. With water the nose turns a little sour, but still some matchstick. Taste is similar, finish seems sweeter with some bbq meat as well. This is pretty good overall, I'll rate it a 4.0.

Glass 5 : On the nose I'm getting a touch of matchstick, sweet candy, very sweet. The taste is matchstick, some burnt sugar, seems around 45% ABV. The finish is peppery tingle, dry, lingers for some time. With water the nose is similar, taste more sweet as is the finish. This was certainly a nice pour, and I'll rate it 4.0.

Glass 2 and 3 were bringing up the rear, and I'll have to say glass 3 was my least favorite, which was the Compass Box. Glass 2 was the Bunnahabhain. These were still very tasty. The next tier had glass 4 and 5... and I'd have to say Glass 5, The Macallan, I enjoyed more than the Ardnamurchan.

Which means Glass 1 was my favorite, The Deer, Bear & Moose 2011. It certainly doesn't seem like it's 59.2% ABV. I do wonder with doing 5 in short succession if there was cross contamination for the nose/taste/finish notes, but all these were mighty tasty.

Saturday, December 13, 2025

24 Days of Whisk(e)y - Day 13

Today was reasonably nice, got out and about for a bit, even got in a 5K run around the neighborhood - and now, time to drink some booze (:

The nose is malt, honey, molasses, marshmallow... I do seem to get a little sulfur or something earthy I can't quite place. At first I thought it might be peated, but the more I smell, the less I'm leaning that way. The taste is peppery, sweet molasses and fresh orange peel. The finish is malt, some pepper and then sweet at the end.

With water, it seems more peppery on the nose, and I think I do get some sulfur too. The taste is sweeter while the finish seems to get a little ashy. I'm guessing this is around 50% ABV and I will rate it a 4.0/5.0 - I do think it's Scotch, and it seems a little thin overall and I think it could be better balanced, but I do enjoy it. 



Ok, not what I was expecting. In the past, I have found Macallan Whisky to be smooth and a bit boring ... but still quite tasty, just not too exciting. This one seemed a little more interesting overall. Macallan Highland Single Malt Scotch Whisky, Sherry Oak Cask, 43% ABV, 12 Year Old. This one cost right about $100, and while I enjoy it enough, I doubt I would buy it again.

Monday, December 12, 2016

Day 12

Today we have Macallan 12 Year Double Cask 40%. I've rarely been disappointed with Macallan, all I have tried have been solid. Nice aroma for this one, somewhat fruity. Taste is a bit of cinnamon I beleive, seems like butterscotch too. Overall, very nice, but a step back from yesterday's offering.