End of the line - and since today is my birthday, I made sure to make it something I like (:
I've reviewed this one before, and it's very nice - especially at the price point of around $60 - $65 for the store pick cask strength version. This came from Westmoreland, and was bottled on 2021-10-20, so it's been around for a while. Hopefully when they run out of these they will do another single barrel store pick (:
On the nose, I get malt and the bbq sweet meat. Some camp fire and a simple syrup sweetness. It reminds me of Ardbeg 10 Year or the 5 Year Wee Beastie - which is a complement. The taste is a bit of a let down compared to the nose, but that's not too surprising. Some is some minty freshness, some meaty sweet, a little honey and marshmallow - with a nice campfire smoke there too. The finish has a lot of the mint tingle that lingers, along with the campfire.
With water I do find more mint on the nose, the taste is more sweet, and the finish is a bit more flat. Some time I need to compare this to other McCarthy's cask strength bottles I have, and maybe against a few Ardbegs too. Last time I rated this 4.25/5.0 - but tonight I think I'll give it a flat 4.0/5.0. Very good, one of the best of the year - but not quite as good as I remembered...
Until next year!