Showing posts with label Old Forester. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Old Forester. Show all posts

Wednesday, October 21, 2026

Whisk(e)y Wednesday 2026-10-21

Time for another Whisk(e)y Wednesday... always fun, here we go (:

On the nose, I get cherry, with some toffee and brown sugar. Seems mid-proof, maybe around 50% ABV... nose screams bourbon to me. The taste ... more of the same - cherry, toffee, maybe a touch of floral ... not enough to get me to budge from bourbon though. The finish, more cherry, then it turns to some wood bite in the back.

With water, the nose is similar but a bit more soft, taste as well. The finish I seem to find more proof and wood. I'll stick with bourbon, around 50% ABV - this seems pretty nice overall, I'll rate it a 3.5/5.0.

This was Old Forester, Oregon Single Barrel, WHSE H Floor 1, 50% ABV. This one cost $60 ... not sure if it's better than the standard Old Foresters that are easy to find, but it wasn't bad. Cheers!

Monday, December 5, 2022

2022 24 Days of Whisk(e)y - Day 5

Happy Monday! Since going to part time, and having Mondays off... they just seem a little better (: Day 5 - today we're drinking Old Forester 1910 Kentucky Bourbon, Double Aged, No Age Statement, distilled and bottled in Kentucky, coming in at 46.5% ABV. We had the Old Forester 1897 on Day 3 - let's see how this one compares.

On the nose, my first impression is toffee and caramel, sweet cream, and a touch of light fruit. The nose is pretty good in my opinion. The taste is hard to put my finger on - I like it, I taste many different things, but I can't quite find what it reminds me of. I get some mint freshness/tingle, and on one of my sips I did find some cinnamon. I get some sweetness, but only a touch. The finish I get some oak and some spice, maybe some sweet chocolate way in the back while it's drifting off.

Adding water, things didn't change much. The nose became more sweet, the taste is probably more sweet as well, with some spicy heat in the back. I get more of a wood finish with water - overall I prefer this one neat. This one costs about $55 ... I probably like this one better than the Old Forester 1897 or the Belle Meade we had on day 2. Or maybe I was just in the mood for this one tonight. Either way, I"m going to give this one a 3.5/5.0 - Cheers!!!


Saturday, December 3, 2022

2022 24 Days of Whisk(e)y - Day 3

Day 3 of 24 Days of Whisk(e)y... tonight, we are having Old Forester 1897, Bottle In Bond, 50% ABV, 'new' version, 4 Year Minimum, distilled and bottled in Kentucky. I have not had this one before, so I have been looking forward to trying this. It's around $55 a bottle, so not cheap, but not overly expensive, let's see how it is:


On the nose, I got sweet cherry, some caramel, and some floral notes. The taste was mostly cherry and a woody note. The finish started out with cherry, then finished with a wood bite that lingered. I didn't particularly like the finish.

With water, it was very similar, a bit sweeter on the nose, and more burn on the finish. Probably better neat. This one was interesting overall, probably not as good as the Belle Meade last night, but certainly better than the 1792 the first night. I'll give it a 'weak' 3.25/5.0, cheers!

Wednesday, January 6, 2021

Whisk(e)y Wednesday - 2021-01-06

Hump Day!!! Whisk(e)y Wednesday ... today I'm doing a blind A/B comparison between Old Forester Rye 50% ABV and Woodford Reserve Rye 45.2% ABV. Both are reasonably priced, let's see which one I think is better.


After pouring the two, I rotated these around until I was sure I didn't know which one was which, other than the label on the bottom of the glass. The first one I sampled turned out to be the Woodford Reserve. On the nose, I got sweet caramel, vanilla, apple, some rye spice and pepper, and a faint hint of dill. The smell reminded me of a bourbon overall.

The taste I got the rye grain and spice, toffee, some fruit. With water things seemed to mellow out a bit, I could take this one either way. The finish was warm with some licorice. This one was interesting, and I'd rate it 3.5 / 5.0 - would drink anytime!

The second sample turned out to be the Old Forester. On the nose I got cherry, sweet and some menthol, with some dill notes in the background. The taste was inline with that, maybe a little bit of pepper too. The finish I got cherry syrup, rye spices, menthol finish along with some pine. Water mellows things out a bit, nothing really changed, I could go either way with this. I feel this one wasn't quite as good at the first, but it was still pretty good overall, rated 3.25 / 5.0 

Around here, Woodford Reserve Rye usually runs around $30 a 750, while Old Forester is $25 or a bit under for a 750. They are both good enough to keep around - but the Woodford is a bit better overall. Cheers!

Wednesday, November 4, 2020

Whisk(e)y Wednesday - 2020-11-04

 Hey look, it's Wednesday again... anything happening this week? Anyway, today we have...


Tonight we're running through some high proof Bourbons to see if any of them stand out among the rest.

We're going to try these side by side, with a reset of Booker's 7 Year that I enjoy to center myself between each one. First up, Stagg Jr - I think Batch 14 from Spring 2020, coming in at 65.1% ABV. On the nose, you can really tell this is high proof, and it's hard to find anything beyond that. Cherry and honey on the taste, with some oak finish. I also get a "tingle" on the finish - possibly from the proof. Adding water, I get a hint of Cinnamon on the nose, and I get it in the taste more too - that was the earlier "tingle". I get more oak as well. Very nice overall - worth finding, but don't pay more than retail price for this one in my opinion. I'd probably add water to this one to bring down the proof a little. Rated 3.75 / 5.0

2nd up is Old Forester 1920 Prohibition Style Bourbon 57.5% ABV. Fruit on the nose with a hint of caramel. Some spice and caramel on the taste. With water the spice comes out a bit more, along with caramel and maple. I probably prefer it straight - nice overall, 3.75 / 5.0

Onto Elijah Craig Barrel Strength, 63.6% ABV. On the nose we have fruit, caramel and some oak. Taste we find vanilla, caramel, spice and oak. I get some fruit in the finish as well. With adding some water I find some cinnamon on the nose, and more oak on the taste. I probably prefer this one straight. Quite tasty overall. 3.75 / 5.0

Finally, we have Russel Reserve Single Barrel coming in at 55% ABV. On the nose we find cinnamon and oak, with a hint of vanilla. Taste I find vanilla, cinnamon and oak. Water doesn't really change things and I would prefer this one straight. Worth buying if you find it at a good price. Rated 3.75 / 5.0

Yes - I rated all 4 of these 3.75. They're different, but none of them stood out. I would say the Stagg Jr is #1 out of the bunch, followed by the Russell's Reserve, then the Elijah Craig and lastly the Old Forrester 1920 - but I would drink the Old Forester any day of the week - so coming in last on this list is nothing to be sad about. The Baker's I was comparing everything to, which I rated at 3.75 as well, I'd say would fit in as between the Russell's Reserve and the Elijah Craig. Cheers!