Wednesday, April 23, 2025
Whisk(e)y Wednesday - 2025-04-23
Wednesday, April 16, 2025
Whisk(e)y Wednesday - 2025-04-16
Happy Wednesday, today we have the last of the 4 sample shootouts, tonight trying the Peaty Scotch Whiskies from 2024 24 Days of Whisk(e)y head to head. We have The Smoky Twelve, Speyside Single Malt Scotch Whisky from BenRiach, Talisker Distiller Edition from 2023, Laphroaig Islay Single Malt Scotch Whisky, 10 Year, Original Cask Strength, and Smokehead High Voltage Islay Single Malt Scotch Whisky, Ian Macleod Distillers. The BenRiach was 46% ABV, the Tailisker was 45.8% ABV, the Laphroaig was 58.5% ABV and the Smokehead was 58% ABV - I was interesting to see how the lower proof pours did against the higher proof pours, as I usually enjoy higher proof whisk(e)y more.
As usual, I poured 1 oz samples of these into marked glasses, randomized them, the nosed and tasted each one. Let's see which one came out on top.
Glass 1 : The nose I get ash, meaty bbq, a touch of brine, savory, rich fruit and a touch of floral. The taste is ash, hot pepper that builds, bbq, hint of brine, sherry fruit notes. The finish starts with hot pepper, then goes to ash and sweet bbq, then back to a hot pepper that lingers along with some tar. Overall this is pretty good.
Glass 2 : On the nose, I get sweet honey molasses, a touch of iodine and burnt wood. The taste is sweet, honey, wood, smoke, iodine in the back, and some sherry fruit. The finish has a burst of fruit up front that lingers, then a touch of smoke, a touch of spice, but mostly the fruit. This is really quite good.
Glass 3 : On the nose, I get orange, ash in the back, sweet bbq meat. The taste is orange cream-sickle, ash, sweet bbq meat, hot pepper in the back. The finish is the hot pepper, then sweet, then ash and peppery that lingers along with a little bit of pepper tingle. This one is pretty good as well.
Glass 4 : Here I get some earthy notes on the nose, sweet bbq, and some strike anywhere matchstick sulphur as well. The taste is burnt char, tar, dirt, sweet bbq, leading to hot peppermint eventually. The finish is sweet sherry, sulphur, earthy dirt, it's nice and lingers. While the sulphur notes that I got were unique, at least tonight I found that it did distract from the whisky overall.
This was a bit tough. All these were pretty good overall, and my palate was certainly getting overwhelmed after running through these from the peat and the higher proofs from some of them. I couldn't specifically say which were the cask strength ones, though I was pretty sure glass 3 was one of the lower proofs. Overall, I felt glass 2 and 4 were better than 1 and 3.
Tasting glass 1 and 3 side by side, I had to give glass 1 the nod. Coming in last place was glass 3, the BenRiach, but even so I would give it a 4.0, which is what I gave it originally as well. In 3rd place was glass 1, which was the Laphroaig. Originally I rated it 4.25 - tonight I would give it a 4.0... a solid whisky for sure.
Drinking glass 2 and 4 side by side, I have to give the edge to glass 2. In glass 4 was the Smokehead. Depending on my mood, I could see this one winning, but I have not been drinking very many peaty scotch whiskies lately, so this might have been a bit too much for me tonight. Originally I gave this a 4.25, tonight I would give it a 4.0.
Leaving us with glass 2, the Talisker. I was surprised by this one during 24 Days of Whisk(e)y - it was just so much better than the previous version that I had several years ago. I would rate this 4.25 tonight, which is what I gave it previously.
Good stuff overall, cheers!!!
Thursday, December 19, 2024
2024 24 Days of Whisk(e)y - Day 19
Thursday! Hey, it's almost the weekend, right? Nearing the end of the line, from the looks of things, we have 1 Peaty Scotch, 3 Non-Peated Scotch, 1 Bourbon, and 1 American Single Malt. What did the dice roll give us for tonight?
On the nose, I'm nearly certain it was the last Peaty Scotch, and it was...
We were drinking Smokehead High Voltage Islay Single Malt Scotch Whisky, Ian Macleod Distillers, 58% ABV, costing $91. I was curious about this one, and I tend to enjoy higher proof Scotch Whiskies.
On the nose, my first initial smell I got black pepper, but then that faded, and I got a touch of rubber, malt, a sweet bbq, and then mesquite and ash. A touch of iodine too, along with a bit of brine. I had a hard time trying to figure out *what* type of smoke I was getting. I am probably due for a palate reset, which I plan on doing in January.
The taste has an initial burst of sweet syrup, followed by hot cinnamon, then to the ash. The finish follows with the sweet and hot cinnamon and then lingers a long time with the char and ash. It's very clingy.
With water, the nose seems a little more smokey, but I still can't quite put a name to it. The taste has a bit more smoke as well, with the finish being more hot cinnamon and black pepper, and it just lingers for a very long time.
I do enjoy this. I'd say both the Taliskers and the Laphroaig from earlier were better balanced, but on some nights, I would likely prefer this one over those. The internet seems to think this is sourced from Ardbeg, or at least used to be. It does have *some* Ardbeg notes, but it's certainly fairly young if it is from Ardbeg. I'll rate it 4.25/5.0
