Showing posts with label Shootout. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Shootout. Show all posts

Wednesday, September 22, 2021

Whisk(e)y Wednesday - 2021-09-22 ... RYE ! ! !

Another Whisk(e)y Wednesday - today... RYE! Trying two higher proof young-ish ryes today. We have Willett Family Estate Small Batch Rye aged 4 years, coming in at 111.8 proof - 55.9% AVB along with Knob Creek Single Barrel (Westmoreland Liquor Store Pick) 115 proof - 57.5% AVB aged 6.25 years or so.


First up, the Knob Creek. On the nose, I find expected rye spice, a touch of dill, some cinnamon and licorice. The taste I get the licorice coming through along with the cinnamon heat. The finish is cinnamon and spice.

With water I get a bit more dill on the nose, more baking spice on the taste, and more wood on the finish. To me this was nothing outstanding, a touch above Old Forester Rye but about twice the price too. Rated 3.25 / 5.0

Next we have the Willett. No batch statement or such on this one. The nose I get brown sugar, a touch of dill, cinnamon and some floral notes. On the taste I get molasses, toasted marshmallow, baking spice, some fruit, and some bitter tea. The finish has spice, some spicy/minty numbing, and a touch of wood.

Water brings out more floral notes on the nose, and brings the bitter tea to the front on the taste for me, along with more molasses - which makes for an interesting combination. Overall this one is interesting, and if you are going to have to hunt down a bottle - you want it to be at least interesting. A step above the Knob Creek - I'd rate it 3.50 / 5.0

I also tried my old standby budget rye - Old Forester 100 proof - and compared to these two, it's a bit flat, but at half the price, probably a better value. I also had a sample of a different Knob Creek Single Barrel Store Pick (same 115 proof) that had more of the typical Knob Creek notes of being nutty and I probably prefer the Westmoreland store pick over that one - but only slightly.

Cheers!

Wednesday, February 17, 2021

Whisk(e)y Wednesday - 2021-02-17

I thought I'd be missing Whisk(e)y Wednesday this week, as we had ice storms around here in suburbia Portland, and I was without internet access until... today! It's a Whisk(e)y miracle! So... the show must go on... 


Today we have three Irish Whiskeys - having two Jameson Whiskey variants, and then a Redbreast 12 Year Cask Strength to compare to. The Redbreast is one of my favorite Irish Whiskeys, so the two Jamesons have their work cut out for them (:

First up, Jameson Blender's Dog. This is triple distilled and comes in at 43% ABV. On the nose I find fresh cut grass, floral, cinnamon and some vanilla. On the taste I get caramel, pepper and wood. The finish is sweet and spicy. With water the nose is similar and the taste is less peppery with more wood. I could drink this either way. Overall this one is pretty good - I don't have the standard Jameson on hand, but from memory I would say this is quite a bit better and more interesting. Rated 3.0 / 5.0

Next we have the Jameson Distiller's Safe, triple distilled, 43% ABV. On the nose we have floral, herbs, almonds and vanilla. The taste I find citrus zest, clove and other baking spices, sweet fruit, and oak. The finish I get spice and dryness that lingers. With water the nose is similar and the taste has a bit more wood sourness and I'm finding nutty as well. Probably better neat. This isn't as good as the Blender's Dog in my opinion, Rated 2.75 / 5.0

Finally, Redbreast Single Pot Still 12 Year Cask Strength Irish Whiskey, Batch B2/19, 55.8% ABV. On the nose I find apple cider, pear and bread. The cask strength is present as you'll want to take small sips for sure. The taste I find butter, spice, baked fruit pie, and wood. The finish I get spice and oak wood that lingers, along with some high proof burn. With water, I found this hotter on the nose, and I find some mint on the flavor that I didn't notice before. I could drink this either way - and for me this is one that deserves to be sampled neat and with water. Overall I find this one really good, Rated 4.0 / 5.0 - it's a keeper for sure.

Wednesday, February 3, 2021

Whisk(e)y Wednesday - 2021-02-03

Hump Day ! ! ! Tonight for Whisk(e)y Wednesday I'm reviewing something I've enjoyed for many years - but have never actually reviewed - Lagavulin 16 Year.


I decided to taste this side by side vs some other scotches. The Lagavulin Distillers Edition (2019 4/508) is one of my favorites, so it's a good baseline to compare to, while the Bank Note Peated Reserve Blended Scotch (5 Year) is a *budget* blend - costing around $25. Where on the scale between these two will the Lagavulin 16 fall? (:

First up, Lagavulin Distillers Edition, Islay Single Malt Scotch Whisky - distilled 2013, bottled 2019, lgv. 4/508, 43% ABV. On the nose I find some mint and floral, a touch of ash and peaty smoke in the background, sweet, vanilla and caramel. On the taste I get some peaty smoke, touch of brine, sweetness and vanilla. The finish I find a fresh mint tingle and a nice sweetness that lingers for some time. Water brings out more mint and floral on the nose, the taste is a bit more tame - I would prefer this neat, but could see people enjoying it with a dash of water. Really well rounded and easy to drink. This one is so good and would be what I would offer a visiting friend or relative if they were visiting. Rated 4.5 / 5.0

Next, Bank Note Blended Scotch Whisky, Peated Reserve 5 Year, 43% ABV. I bought this mostly to see if a $25 Peated Blend would be half way decent. On the nose I get some smoke, sweet fruit, toffee and a bit of floral. The taste I get ashy smoke, some sweet and a hint of dark chocolate. On the finish I find it a bit bitter and harsh. Some spice with a sweet aftertaste turning a bit metallic. With water the nose is similar, a touch less harsh on the taste - might prefer this one with a splash of water. Overall - this one tastes a bit off at first, but by the time you're finishing the pour, it seems all right. There are things that are not much more, Compass Box Great King Street Artist's Blend, for example - that are much more enjoyable - though not peated. Rated 2.5 / 5.0

Onto the Lagavulin 16, 43% ABV. On the nose I find sweet caramel, some peat smoke, vanilla and iodine. The taste for me is salt and pepper, some earthy smoke, and nice balance. The finish I get mint freshness and pepper that hangs around for some time. With water I get more spice on the nose, and it tames the taste a bit - I prefer this one neat. Overall this one is well balanced, and will always be on my shelf. I don't enjoy it as much as the Lagavulin Distiller Edition - but it's close. Rated 4.25 / 5.0

Thursday, January 28, 2021

Whisk(e)y Wednesday - 2021-01-27

Woo! Hump Day ... Whisk(e)y Wednesday yet again. Note that I got lazy last night and didn't get around to posting this review - but I have all my notes so here goes. I thought I'd run through some different Westward Single Malts - I have samples of the Pinot Noir Cask 45% ABV and the Cask Stout 45% ABV, along with a bottle of the Single Barrel Women of Westward 45% ABV release. Will one stand out among the others? Will there be much difference?



I did this blind, but it was easy to pick the Pinot Noir Cask out - and I was pretty sure between the Single Barrel and Cask Stout versions as well. First up, the Single Barrel Women of Westward release. This came out in 2017, and I picked up a 375ml bottle a month or so ago. The nose I get fruit along with some dark chocolate in the background. The taste is licorice and tea, the tea note being similar to the standard Westward Single Malt release. On the finish I get grass and some spice. With water, the nose opens up for me and has more chocolate, a little less bite on the taste and a bit more sweetness, I could have this either way. This is better than the standard Westward, but the cask strength Westward is better in every way. Given the price of this, I can't see buying again. 3.5 / 5.0

Next up was the Pinot Noir Cask version. On the nose I found sweetness, fruit, and grass. The taste I got grass, fruit and old leather in the background. The finish was a touch of fruit, not too heavy, and some tobacco. With water the nose is more interesting - ripe fruit, multilayered, but sadly the taste is more dull. I could drink this either way. Of the three tonight, this was probably my favorite, 3.5 / 5.0

Finally I tried the Cask Stout. I didn't really find any stout on this one in the nose, taste, or finish. The nose was fruit, some citrus and cinnamon. The taste I got the bitter tea like the standard Westward, some nuts, a hint of brine, and some wood. The finish was dry with some tea. Water brought out some citrus on the nose, and some fruit on the taste, but still heavy on the tea. This one was the most like the standard Westward Single Malt - but I probably like this a little better. It was my least favorite of the three, but possibly because it was the least different. 3.25 / 5.0

Wednesday, January 20, 2021

Whisk(e)y Wednesday - 2021-01-20

Hump Day!!! Time for another blind taste test. Today I'm trying Black Maple Hill Small Batch Limited Edition, 47.5% ABV vs. Starward Two-Fold Double Grain Australian Whisky 40.0% ABV vs Westward American Single Malt Whiskey, 45.0% ABV. I poured the three glasses and then mixed them up until I didn't know which was which...


Sample A: On the nose I found cinnamon and honey, wasn't overpowering, fairly subtile. The taste was rye like spice, floral, herbs, caramel and some maple. The finish had spice that lingered for quite some time - but wasn't overly strong. A dash of water made it more floral on the nose and more rye spice, with the taste becoming more bitter - I would prefer this neat. Rated this 3.5 / 5.0 - This one turned out to be the Black Maple Hill. While it was good, at about $90 a bottle it would be hard justifying purchasing.

Sample B: On the nose I got eucalyptus and tea coming through. The taste I found bitter tea, some grain funk, orange and some ripe fruit. The finish gave me a long herbal finish, bitter tea, and some wood. With water I found the nose more enjoyable - relaxed and inviting. Still got the bitter tea on the taste with some spice as well, I probably liked this one a bit more with water. Rated 3.25 / 5. 0 - This was the Westward. Once I noticed the bitter black tea it was hard to ignore, but I thought it was pretty good overall. At about $70 a bottle I can't see buying this again though.

Sample C: On the nose I got pepper, mint and orange juice. The taste was suite fruit and wood. The finish was dry wood with some spice heat as well. With water I got a bit more sour on the nose - possibly wood along with apple. Fruity on the taste, but the finish seemed more thin, would prefer this one neat. Rated 3.25 / 5.0 - This was the Starward , and was all right overall. At about $32 a bottle, it held its own vs the two other higher priced Whiskies tonight. 

While the Black Maple Hill was the best of the three in my opinion - the Starward was clearly the best value. They make a single malt that I might have to try. Cheers!

Wednesday, January 13, 2021

Whisk(e)y Wednesday - 2021-01-13

Yet another hump day, woot! Whisk(e)y Wednesday - or more accurately Whisk(e)y Monday as I had these Monday but didn't get around to posting until tonight. We're going to try 3 high proof whisk(e)y - 2 American Single Malts and 1 Kentucky Straight Bourbon. 


We have Balcones Texas Single Malt Whisky, Single Barrel, Cask Strength. This one is coming in at 64.9% ABV, barrel 15961, European Oak, Distilled 2017-01-10, bottled 2020-08-04. Next we have Westward American Single Malt Cask Strength, 62.5% ABV (NAS). Lastly we have the control whiskey - Old Grand Dad 114 Straight Kentucky Bourbon (at least 4 years), which given it was a bourbon, I was likely going to be able to pick out. If the $80ish Balcones and the $100ish Westward don't taste any better than the $30ish Old Grand Dad - it's time to stick with lower priced pours (:

I poured these and shuffled them around to do a blind taste test. First glass, on the nose I had toasted marshmallow, touch of smoke or campfire char, molasses and some alcohol punch. On the taste I got candy corn, caramel, sugary, oak and some grain funk. The finish was punchy with some minty freshness that seemed to linger. A dash of water tames the alcohol on the nose, ramping up the sweetness. The taste got a bit more sharp - I probably prefer this one neat. Overall I enjoyed this quite a bit, and I could see sitting with a glass for a nice relaxing evening. Rated 3.75 / 5.0

Second one was a bit bland on the nose, getting some caramel, brown sugar, citrus and some baking spice, but somewhat having to reach for them. The taste was sweet, caramel, spicy and peppery. The finish was somewhat thin, with some alcohol burn, pepper and some oak. Water opened the sweetness on the nose, and I found some nutmeg as well. It smoothed out the taste, more wood on the finish, probably would prefer with a splash of water. This is good overall, and worth keeping around - my guess is this was is the Old Grand Dad 114 (spoiler - yep). Rated 3.25 / 5.0

Last one ... this I find sweet candy, fruit, oak and a hit of spice on the nose. The taste I find butterscotch, brown sugar and frosting. The finish was lingering, fruity, spice and wood that goes on and on. With water the nose turns to nothing but sweetness for me, more spicy on the taste. I prefer this one neat. This is shockingly easy to drink despite being over 120 proof. Rated 3.75 / 5.0

#1 and #3 are very close for me preference wise. They are different, I'd lean towards #1. I guessed #1 was the Balcones because of the touch of smoke on the nose, #2 I thought was Old Grand Dad, and #3 I thought was the Westward. Turned out I had The Balcones and the Westward swapped - the slight grain funk in #1 should have led me to know it was Westward, as the non-cask strength single malt has the same grain funk. So of the three, the Westward Cask Strength was the slight winner.

The Balcones Single Malt was a store pick and likely will not see it again - but if I see another Cask Strength Single Barrel Balcones Single Malt, I might pick it up. The Westward Cask Strength is fairly easy to find around here since it's made in Portland, OR, but at $100 a bottle it's more of a special occasion pour. The Old Grand Dad 114, at $30 is a steal - likely a bottle to always keep around - my guess is with the high proof it would stand up well to water, ice or mixing. 


Wednesday, January 6, 2021

Whisk(e)y Wednesday - 2021-01-06

Hump Day!!! Whisk(e)y Wednesday ... today I'm doing a blind A/B comparison between Old Forester Rye 50% ABV and Woodford Reserve Rye 45.2% ABV. Both are reasonably priced, let's see which one I think is better.


After pouring the two, I rotated these around until I was sure I didn't know which one was which, other than the label on the bottom of the glass. The first one I sampled turned out to be the Woodford Reserve. On the nose, I got sweet caramel, vanilla, apple, some rye spice and pepper, and a faint hint of dill. The smell reminded me of a bourbon overall.

The taste I got the rye grain and spice, toffee, some fruit. With water things seemed to mellow out a bit, I could take this one either way. The finish was warm with some licorice. This one was interesting, and I'd rate it 3.5 / 5.0 - would drink anytime!

The second sample turned out to be the Old Forester. On the nose I got cherry, sweet and some menthol, with some dill notes in the background. The taste was inline with that, maybe a little bit of pepper too. The finish I got cherry syrup, rye spices, menthol finish along with some pine. Water mellows things out a bit, nothing really changed, I could go either way with this. I feel this one wasn't quite as good at the first, but it was still pretty good overall, rated 3.25 / 5.0 

Around here, Woodford Reserve Rye usually runs around $30 a 750, while Old Forester is $25 or a bit under for a 750. They are both good enough to keep around - but the Woodford is a bit better overall. Cheers!

Wednesday, December 30, 2020

Whisk(e)y Wednesday - 2020-12-30

Almost the New Years - Hump Day!!! and... Whiskey Wednesday. Today I'm doing a budget bourbon shootout - doing a blind tasting of Eagle Rare, Evan Williams Single Barrel, and Wild Turkey 101. I don't usually do blind tastings - normally I know what I'm trying, I have looked at reviews for some ideas of what to expect on the nose/palate - so today... it's going to be interesting.


I labelled the glasses on the bottom, and then after pouring I randomized the order (which is easier to do the older I get...) until I felt confident I had no idea which glass was where. 

Glass #1. On the nose I got sweet, flowery, vanilla, and some brown sugar. The taste I found a touch of spice, some burnt brown sugar, and a bit of mint. The finish was charred sugar and a bit of metallic shiny notes. With water the sweetness pops on the nose, more brown sugar, with burnt sugar and some oak on the taste. Rated 3.25 / 5.0 - seemed a little better with water.

Glass #2. On the nose my first thought is mustard, which is odd as it's not a note I think I've came across before... some grass and dill pickle as well. The taste is neutral - I kept going back trying to find something, but it just wasn't there. The finish is minty with some oak notes. With water it's a bit more traditional on the nose - I've lost the mustard and dill. More metallic on the finish and a bit sour on the taste. Rated 3.0 / 5.0 - I found it better neat.

Glass #3. On the nose, I found this floral, touch of cinnamon, and some licorice. The taste is spicy with a bit of metallic. The finish I am finding licorice and a minty finish. With water, I get more floral on the nose, more licorice and wood oak on the finish, along with a spicy taste. Rated 3.25 / 5.0. I could drink this either straight or with a dash of water.

#1 was Wild Turkey 101, 50.5% ABV, Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey. I grew up thinking Wild Turkey was rotgut... but apparently not the case, as this edged out #3 for me as the best of the three. No age statement - which I think would be aged at least 3 years as this is a 'straight bourbon', though online I see comments that state it's 6 years old, so I'm not sure.

#2 was Evan Williams Single Barrel, 43.3% ABV, aged about 8 years (put in oak 2012, bottled 2020). This came in last place for me, but was still pretty good overall. I recall really liking this in the past, so maybe the current batch isn't as good as the old batches. 

#3 was Eagle Rare, Aged 10 Years, 45% ABV. It can sometimes be hard to find, but at around $30 it's certainly worth the price. While in the A/B comparison I felt the Wild Turkey was slightly better - they are really close.

This was a fun experiment - I'll need to do more blind tastings ... cheers!

Wednesday, November 25, 2020

Whisk(e)y Wednesday - 2020-11-25

Hump Day! And I had the day off ... and the next 4 days off too, woo... Time to celebrate! Today I'm doing a head to head comparison between Maker's Mark Private Select, coming in at 54.5% ABV and Remus Repeal Reserve Series IV Straight Bourbon Whiskey, 50% ABV, aged 12 years.


First up, Maker's Mark. On the nose, I get oak and some brown sugar, along with some cinnamon, clove and other spices. Nothing too surprising on the taste, certainly Maker's Mark, with brown sugar, cinnamon. and spice. Water seems to bring out the sweetness and brown sugar, while rounding off the edges - I probably prefer it with some water. I'll rate it 3.5 / 5.0.

Onto Remus Repeal Reserve. I reviewed Series II and liked it, so I split a bottle of Series IV with a friend. Very nice on the nose, with caramel and toffee and a hint of wood. The taste has a nice rye like spice along with some caramel. Quite good. For me, water brings out more of the wood. I prefer this one neat. I think I like this one over the Maker's Mark, I'll rate it 3.75 / 5.0 (which is the same rating I gave Series II). Cheers, and Happy Thanksgiving (:

Wednesday, November 4, 2020

Whisk(e)y Wednesday - 2020-11-04

 Hey look, it's Wednesday again... anything happening this week? Anyway, today we have...


Tonight we're running through some high proof Bourbons to see if any of them stand out among the rest.

We're going to try these side by side, with a reset of Booker's 7 Year that I enjoy to center myself between each one. First up, Stagg Jr - I think Batch 14 from Spring 2020, coming in at 65.1% ABV. On the nose, you can really tell this is high proof, and it's hard to find anything beyond that. Cherry and honey on the taste, with some oak finish. I also get a "tingle" on the finish - possibly from the proof. Adding water, I get a hint of Cinnamon on the nose, and I get it in the taste more too - that was the earlier "tingle". I get more oak as well. Very nice overall - worth finding, but don't pay more than retail price for this one in my opinion. I'd probably add water to this one to bring down the proof a little. Rated 3.75 / 5.0

2nd up is Old Forester 1920 Prohibition Style Bourbon 57.5% ABV. Fruit on the nose with a hint of caramel. Some spice and caramel on the taste. With water the spice comes out a bit more, along with caramel and maple. I probably prefer it straight - nice overall, 3.75 / 5.0

Onto Elijah Craig Barrel Strength, 63.6% ABV. On the nose we have fruit, caramel and some oak. Taste we find vanilla, caramel, spice and oak. I get some fruit in the finish as well. With adding some water I find some cinnamon on the nose, and more oak on the taste. I probably prefer this one straight. Quite tasty overall. 3.75 / 5.0

Finally, we have Russel Reserve Single Barrel coming in at 55% ABV. On the nose we find cinnamon and oak, with a hint of vanilla. Taste I find vanilla, cinnamon and oak. Water doesn't really change things and I would prefer this one straight. Worth buying if you find it at a good price. Rated 3.75 / 5.0

Yes - I rated all 4 of these 3.75. They're different, but none of them stood out. I would say the Stagg Jr is #1 out of the bunch, followed by the Russell's Reserve, then the Elijah Craig and lastly the Old Forrester 1920 - but I would drink the Old Forester any day of the week - so coming in last on this list is nothing to be sad about. The Baker's I was comparing everything to, which I rated at 3.75 as well, I'd say would fit in as between the Russell's Reserve and the Elijah Craig. Cheers!